News Analysis — 16 November 2026
Privacy vs Press Freedom: News Publishers Challenge the DPDP Act in the Supreme Court
The Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA), representing 21 publishers, has asked the Supreme Court to stay parts of the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023. It argues that the law has no exemption for journalism, so reporters could need the consent of the very people they investigate. The Court issued notice on 27 October but declined an immediate stay; the matter returns for hearing on Tuesday (17 November).
- Press freedom is not separately named in the Constitution. It is part of freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) (Romesh Thappar, 1950; Indian Express Newspapers, 1985).
- It can be limited only on the grounds in Article 19(2) — sovereignty and integrity, security of the State, friendly relations with foreign States, public order, decency or morality, contempt of court, defamation, incitement to an offence.
- Privacy is a Fundamental Right under Article 21 and Part III — K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), nine-judge bench.
- Any restriction on privacy must pass Puttaswamy’s proportionality test: legality (a law), legitimate aim, proportionality (least restrictive means) and procedural safeguards.
- The clash: journalism often needs to collect and publish personal data — names, transactions, conduct — without the subject’s consent. Data protection law, by default, requires that consent.
- The Act could impede investigative journalism, expose confidential sources, force removal of published reports (via the right to erasure) and deter whistleblowers.
- Asking journalists to seek consent from the subjects of their reports would amount to a regime of ‘pre-censorship’.
- The missing exemption: earlier drafts — the Srikrishna Committee’s 2018 Bill and the Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019 — carried an exemption for journalistic purposes; the 2023 Act dropped it.
- Separate petitions also challenge the Act’s amendment to Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, which removed the public-interest override for personal information.
- R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu (1994) — the ‘Auto Shankar case’: a public official cannot claim privacy to block scrutiny of acts done in an official capacity; but public office does not open every part of private life. The State cannot impose prior restraint on publication on privacy grounds.
- Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2010) — warned against trial by media that turns an accused into a convict before the verdict.
- Sahara India Real Estate Corp. v. SEBI (2012) — courts may issue temporary postponement orders on reporting if publicity poses a real and substantial risk to a fair trial.
- R.K. Anand v. Registrar, Delhi High Court (2009) — upheld a sting operation that exposed an attempt to suborn a witness in the BMW case, as serving a public cause.
- Rajat Prasad v. CBI (2014) — public interest does not grant blanket immunity for unlawful acts committed during a sting.
- International law: Articles 17 (privacy) and 19 (expression) of the ICCPR; Articles 8 and 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
- Axel Springer AG v. Germany (2012) — the ECtHR Grand Chamber ruled 12–5 that restricting a newspaper’s report on an actor’s arrest violated press freedom; the press is a public watchdog.
- USA: First Amendment (1791); the Privacy Protection Act, 1980 limits searches of journalists’ unpublished work.
- UK: Data Protection Act, 2018 — exemption where publication is reasonably believed to be in the public interest.
- Brazil: General Data Protection Law excludes journalistic processing; Kenya: Section 52 of its Data Protection Act, 2019 gives a conditional exemption.
- Who is a journalist? In the digital age, anyone can publish; a broad exemption could shield doxxing, data brokers or harassment campaigns posing as ‘news’.
- Victims’ rights: survivors of crime, minors and private individuals need protection from intrusive coverage — the concern behind the Manu Sharma and Sahara rulings.
- The Government’s stated view is that the Act does not curb press freedom; the general law on defamation and contempt already applies to the press.
- A narrow, proportionate journalism exemption — tied to public interest, editorial responsibility and a code of ethics (on the GDPR Article 85 model).
- Source protection written into law, so data requests cannot be used to unmask whistleblowers.
- Clear guidance from the Data Protection Board on how consent, erasure and access rights apply to news archives.
- Harmonise the DPDP Act with the RTI Act by restoring a public-interest test.
“The right to privacy and the freedom of the press are both essential to democracy, yet they frequently collide.” In the light of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, examine how this conflict can be reconciled. 15 marks · 250 words
Bangladesh’s Former PM in India: No Passport, an Extradition Demand and a Diplomatic Dilemma
Former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, in India since 5 August 2024, applied on 9 November for a new passport and national ID card, saying she wishes to return in December. Dhaka has refused, calling her a ‘terrorist’, and insists she be returned through extradition. Her position puts India’s legal obligations, diplomacy and humanitarian traditions to the test.
- July–August 2024: a student-led uprising against her 15-year rule ended with her flight to India on 5 August 2024. A UN report estimated about 1,400 deaths in the crackdown.
- November 2025: Bangladesh’s International Crimes Tribunal (ICT) sentenced her to death in absentia for crimes against humanity, for ordering the police crackdown. She denies giving such orders.
- Now: her party’s activities remain banned; a new elected government is in office in Dhaka.
- Extradition: the formal surrender of a person by one State to another for trial or punishment, under a treaty and domestic law.
- Repatriation: return of a person to their own country — needs a valid travel document (passport or an emergency certificate).
- Dual criminality: the act must be an offence in both countries.
- Political offence exception: a long-standing rule that States need not extradite for offences of a political character.
- Signed: 2013 — mainly to tackle cross-border insurgency and terrorism; amended in 2016.
- Extraditable offence: punishable with at least one year of imprisonment, with dual criminality.
- Article 6: extradition may be refused for offences of a political character — but serious crimes such as murder, terrorism-related offences and kidnapping are excluded from that defence.
- Article 7: may be refused if the person can be tried in the requested State’s own courts.
- Article 8: may be refused if the accusation is not made in good faith in the interests of justice, or concerns purely military offences.
- 2016 amendment, Article 10(3): a warrant from a competent court of the requesting State is enough; prima facie evidence is no longer required.
- Indian law: the Extradition Act, 1962 — a magistrate inquires, and the Central Government takes the final decision; Section 31 bars surrender for political offences.
- Treaty obligation: the charges (killings during a crackdown) fall in the categories the treaty excludes from the political-offence defence.
- Grounds to hesitate: a death sentence in absentia and concerns over fair trial may support an Article 8 ‘good faith’ refusal; extradition also stays the Centre’s discretion.
- Asylum gap: India has no national refugee law and is not a party to the 1951 Refugee Convention; it shelters people case by case.
- Strategic stakes: Bangladesh shares India’s longest land border (about 4,096 km), is its largest trade partner in South Asia, and is central to Northeast connectivity and security.
- Live agenda: the Ganga Water Treaty (1996) runs for 30 years and falls due for renewal in December 2026; the Teesta issue remains unresolved.
- A return via the Benapole–Petrapole land port could draw large crowds of supporters and opponents, risking clashes at the border.
- Recent arson incidents and labour unrest in the readymade garment sector already stretch the security machinery.
- The police still suffer low legitimacy after their role in the 2024 crackdown.
- Politically, her return could energise the left and centre-left against a spectrum now dominated by the centre-right and right.
- Petrapole (West Bengal)–Benapole (Bangladesh): the busiest land port for India–Bangladesh trade; Petrapole has an Integrated Check Post run by the Land Ports Authority of India.
- International Crimes Tribunal — set up under Bangladesh’s International Crimes (Tribunals) Act, 1973, first to try 1971 war crimes.
- Rapid Action Battalion (RAB) — Bangladesh’s elite anti-crime and counter-terror force.
- Extradition Act, 1962 — administered by the Ministry of External Affairs.
The demand for the extradition of Bangladesh’s former Prime Minister places India between treaty obligations and strategic prudence. Discuss the legal provisions involved and suggest how India should balance its interests. 15 marks · 250 words
Rebalancing India’s Rice Economy: Exporting More Value, Not More Water
India is the world’s largest rice exporter, yet much of that rice is grown with scarce groundwater. Its exports therefore carry hidden water and carbon costs. The authors argue India should shift from exporting more tonnes to earning more value per tonne and per drop.
Virtual water is the water used to produce a good. When a country exports rice, it is in effect exporting the water that grew it — the concept is credited to geographer Tony Allan (1990s).
- Green water: rainfall stored in the soil — little strain on local resources.
- Blue water: water drawn from aquifers, rivers and reservoirs — a scarce, shrinking stock.
- Grey water: water needed to dilute pollutants (e.g. fertiliser run-off).
- The point: rain-fed rice from the east is very different from groundwater-fed rice in the northwest, even if both fetch the same export price.
- Kharif crop needing high temperature, high humidity and above ~100 cm rainfall; grown under irrigation where rain is short (Punjab, Haryana).
- Leading States: Uttar Pradesh, Telangana, West Bengal, Punjab, Chhattisgarh, Odisha, MP, Bihar, AP and Tamil Nadu.
- Production 2025–26: about 154.02 million tonnes (estimate).
- Largest exporter since 2012, with about 30–35% of global rice exports in recent years.
- Basmati GI: registered in 2016 for the Indo-Gangetic plains of Punjab, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Delhi, Uttarakhand, western UP and parts of J&K. Exports are promoted by APEDA (Ministry of Commerce).
- Recent policy swings: curbs on broken rice and non-basmati exports in 2022–23 (to protect domestic stocks) were lifted in 2024.
- Water: pressure is most acute in Punjab, Haryana and western UP, where groundwater extraction far exceeds recharge; groundwater-fed rice in parts of the east and south adds to it.
- Carbon: flooded paddies produce methane (anaerobic decomposition); excess nitrogen fertiliser releases nitrous oxide.
- Energy: free or cheap farm power for pumps encourages over-extraction.
- Policy lock-in: assured MSP procurement of paddy keeps water-intensive rice attractive in dry regions.
- Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD): fields are allowed to dry periodically instead of staying flooded — saves water and cuts methane.
- Direct-Seeded Rice (DSR): seeds sown directly, skipping nursery and puddled transplanting — saves water and labour.
- Integrated Nutrient Management: balanced use of chemical, organic and bio-fertilisers.
- Caution: results vary with soil and agro-climate; drying fields can cut methane but raise nitrous oxide — a trade-off between gases.
- From volume to value: ‘more crop per drop, more income per tonne, less energy per unit exported’.
- Align rice with agro-climatic zones and groundwater status; incentivise crop diversification in water-stressed areas.
- Raise export value via quality, branding, traceability, processing and GIs.
- Track new metrics: export value per cubic metre of blue water, groundwater used per tonne, emissions per kg, and farmer income per unit of water.
- Existing levers: PMKSY — ‘Per Drop More Crop’ (2015), Atal Bhujal Yojana, Punjab’s Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009 (delays transplanting), Haryana’s Mera Pani Meri Virasat.
“India exports not just rice but scarce groundwater.” Examine the concept of virtual water trade in this context and suggest measures to make India’s rice exports sustainable. 15 marks · 250 words
Microsoft 365 Outage: How a ‘Cascading Failure’ Disrupted Millions — and the Risk of Cloud Concentration
From 13 November, a widespread outage hit Microsoft 365, especially services linked to Exchange Online (email, calendars, contacts). It affected businesses in at least 74 countries; Microsoft has about 450 million paid Microsoft 365 subscriptions. The company said there was no sign of a cyberattack.
- Cloud computing: using computing resources over the internet instead of on your own machines.
- Service models: IaaS (rented servers), PaaS (platforms to build apps), SaaS (ready software, e.g. Microsoft 365, Gmail).
- How email travels: your app → outgoing mail server → recipient’s server (spam check) → mailbox. If the receiving server is down, the sender’s server queues and retries; Microsoft extended this timeout to 48 hours — not a 48-hour shutdown.
- Network perimeter: the infrastructure handling traffic entering or leaving a company’s network.
- Email and calendars failed; Teams calls worked for some, failed for others; Admin Center, file access and Microsoft 365 Education tools were hit.
- Security risk: Defender for Office 365’s Safe Links may not have been able to check URLs — opening a window for phishing.
- US and Australian government bodies acknowledged an impact on operations.
- It follows an earlier long Microsoft 365 outage from 31 August 2026, and the July 2024 CrowdStrike incident that crashed millions of Windows machines worldwide.
- A handful of global providers run the cloud backbone of businesses and governments; one failure becomes a single point of failure for many.
- Lock-in: services are deeply integrated, cheap at scale, bundled for discounts and limited in interoperability; switching means high cost and retraining.
- Repeated calls to diversify providers have seen little action.
- CERT-In — national nodal agency for cyber incidents, Section 70B, IT Act, 2000; its 2022 directions require incidents to be reported within 6 hours.
- NCIIPC — protects Critical Information Infrastructure, Section 70A, under the NTRO.
- MeghRaj — the Government of India’s cloud initiative; MeitY empanels cloud service providers.
- RBI Master Direction on outsourcing of IT services (2023) — banks remain responsible for risks from vendors.
- Global model: the EU’s Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA), applicable from January 2025, oversees critical ICT providers to the financial sector.
Recurring global cloud outages show that digital resilience is now a matter of national security. Discuss the risks of dependence on a few cloud providers and suggest measures for India. 10 marks · 150 words
Place in News — Mekedatu: Karnataka Pushes the Cauvery Balancing Reservoir; Tamil Nadu Objects
Karnataka’s Chief Minister has said the State will go ahead with the Mekedatu Balancing Reservoir on the Cauvery, calling it Karnataka’s ‘right and duty’, while assuring Tamil Nadu its Supreme Court-fixed share of 177.25 tmc ft. Karnataka says it is preparing the forest and environmental clearance documents; Tamil Nadu continues to oppose the project.
- Location: at the confluence of the Cauvery and the Arkavathi, about 100 km from Bengaluru, near the Karnataka–Tamil Nadu border (Bengaluru South, formerly Ramanagara, and Chamarajanagar districts). ‘Mekedatu’ means ‘goat’s leap’ in Kannada — a narrow gorge.
- Type: balancing reservoir-cum-drinking water project.
- Storage: about 67 tmc ft (earlier DPR: 67.16 tmc gross).
- Purpose: 4.75 tmc ft of drinking water for Bengaluru and nearby areas, plus about 400 MW of hydropower.
- Submergence: about 5,000 hectares, much of it forest in the Cauvery Wildlife Sanctuary; the Centre wants compensatory land for the forest lost.
- Status: the Supreme Court (13 November 2025) called Tamil Nadu’s challenge ‘premature’ while expert bodies review the DPR; the Central Water Commission has sought a revised DPR.
- Source: Talakaveri, Brahmagiri hills, Kodagu (Karnataka); flows about 800 km to the Bay of Bengal near Poompuhar, Tamil Nadu.
- Basin States: Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and the UT of Puducherry.
- Left-bank tributaries: Harangi, Hemavati, Shimsha, Arkavathi. Right-bank: Lakshmanatirtha, Kabini, Suvarnavati, Bhavani, Noyyal, Amaravati.
- Waterfalls: Shivanasamudra (Karnataka; site of one of Asia’s earliest hydropower stations, 1902) and Hogenakkal (Tamil Nadu).
- Dams: Krishna Raja Sagara (KRS) in Mandya; Mettur (Stanley Reservoir) in Tamil Nadu; Grand Anicut (Kallanai), attributed to Karikala Chola — among the oldest working water-regulation structures in the world.
- Its delta splits into the Kollidam (northern branch) and the Cauvery proper — the ‘rice bowl’ of Tamil Nadu (Thanjavur).
- 1892 and 1924 agreements between the Madras Presidency and the princely State of Mysore.
- Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal (CWDT) set up in 1990; interim order 1991; final award 2007.
- Supreme Court, 16 February 2018 (State of Karnataka v. State of Tamil Nadu): reallocated shares; raised Karnataka’s share by 14.75 tmc (incl. 4.75 tmc for Bengaluru’s drinking water); cut Tamil Nadu’s required flow at Biligundlu from 192 to 177.25 tmc. It treated drinking water as the highest priority.
- Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) and Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC) — set up in 2018 under the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956, to implement the award.
- Karnataka: the reservoir is within its territory; it will store surplus flood water that now flows unused to the sea, meet Bengaluru’s drinking water needs, and still release Tamil Nadu’s share — even help regulate releases in lean years.
- Tamil Nadu: any new storage upstream of Biligundlu gives Karnataka control over flows; the 2018 verdict did not permit new projects without the consent of all basin States; the 4.75 tmc for Bengaluru does not need a 67-tmc dam.
- Environment: submergence of sanctuary forest, loss of elephant corridors and habitat of the grizzled giant squirrel and hump-backed mahseer — Cauvery endemics.
- Water is a State subject (Entry 17, State List), subject to Entry 56, Union List (regulation of inter-State rivers).
- Article 262: Parliament may provide for adjudication of inter-State river disputes and bar the jurisdiction of courts.
- Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 (tribunals) and the River Boards Act, 1956.
- Even so, the Supreme Court hears appeals against tribunal awards under Article 136, as it did in 2018.
- Karnataka asked the Centre to reject the Kasturirangan report on the Western Ghats (see Also in News).
- It reported its farm-power subsidy for irrigation pump sets has risen from about ₹20,000 crore to ₹30,000 crore, attributed to drought and lift irrigation schemes.
Inter-State river disputes in India persist even after tribunal awards and Supreme Court verdicts. Discuss with reference to the Mekedatu project, and suggest institutional reforms for cooperative river basin management. 15 marks · 250 words
Poompuhar: Underwater Exploration Yields Evidence of a Sangam-Era Port’s West Asian Trade
The Tamil Nadu State Department of Archaeology (TNSDA) has completed three phases of underwater exploration off Poompuhar (Sept 2025–Sept 2026). It found ring wells, over 250 ceramic pieces and a fragment of a torpedo jar — the first found in an underwater survey — pointing to trade with West Asia.
- Location: where the Cauvery meets the Bay of Bengal, in present-day Mayiladuthurai district, Tamil Nadu.
- Port-capital of the early Cholas, associated with Karikala Chola.
- Literary sources:
- Silappadikaram (attributed to Ilango Adigal) — the story of Kovalan and Kannagi opens in Puhar.
- Manimekalai (Seethalai Sathanar) — a Buddhist epic; describes Puhar being engulfed by the sea.
- Pattinappalai (part of the Pattuppattu) — praises Karikala and the bustle of the port.
- City layout (per literature): Maruvurpakkam (seaside — foreign merchants, spice and perfume sellers, weavers), Pattinappakkam (temples, royals, nobles) and Naalangadi (the day market) between them.
- Area: a 16-km stretch between Thirumullaivasal (north) and Vanagiri (south), up to 6 km out to sea, in four zones; the 2–5.5 km zone was most productive.
- Torpedo jar fragment: a long, narrow-mouthed jar used to ship liquids such as wine or fish oil, believed to be from West Asia. Earlier found on land at Alagankulam, Korkai and Porpanaikottai.
- Ceramics: glazed ware, red ware and black-and-red ware, with bowls, plates and storage jars.
- Ring wells (60–65 cm diameter) — suggest a former palaeochannel and settlement.
- Shipwreck (~4.5 km offshore, ~20 m deep, likely 18th century): four more lead ingots found; earlier ingots bear ‘W. Blackett’ and 1792. Being recorded by photogrammetry (3D models built from many photographs).
- 1980s: S.R. Rao (also known for Lothal and Dwarka) with the National Institute of Oceanography (NIO), Goa used side-scan sonar and found ‘anomalies’ at ~20 m depth.
- 1991: TNSDA divers located the shipwreck off Vanagiri and possible man-made structures.
- Next: TNSDA plans a fresh proposal to the Archaeological Survey of India, resuming in January–February after the monsoon.
- Adds West Asian links to the known Roman trade (Roman coins found at Poompuhar).
- Fits a network of early historic ports: Arikamedu (Puducherry), Korkai (Pandya), Muziris (Chera, Kerala), Alagankulam.
- The Periplus of the Erythraean Sea (1st century CE) lists the ports of the Tamil coast, including one identified with Kaveripattinam.
- Corroborates Sangam literature with physical evidence — strengthening the case for the antiquity of Tamil urbanism, alongside land excavations such as Keezhadi.
How far do recent archaeological findings corroborate the picture of maritime trade presented in Sangam literature? Discuss with reference to Poompuhar. 10 marks · 150 words
Wangala Festival Turns 50 with a 1,000-Drum Guinness World Record
The Garo community’s Wangala harvest festival marked its golden jubilee near Tura (Meghalaya) with 1,000 drummers playing the dama and about 1,500 women dancers, setting a Guinness World Record. Also called the ‘100 Drums Festival’, it was given a formal shape in 1976 with just 10 drums.
- Prelims hook: Wangala honours Saljong, the Sun God; marks the end of the harvest and the onset of winter. The dama is a long drum (~4 ft). The Garos are a matrilineal tribe of the Garo Hills (five districts). Compare: Nagaland’s Hornbill Festival (1–10 December, Kisama).
Karnataka Seeks Rejection of the Kasturirangan Report on the Western Ghats
Karnataka’s Chief Minister has urged the Centre to reject the Kasturirangan report, which proposes declaring parts of the Western Ghats an Ecologically Sensitive Area (ESA). States fear curbs on settlements, farming and infrastructure.
- Prelims hook: Gadgil Committee (WGEEP, 2011) recommended about 64% of the Ghats as eco-sensitive zones; the Kasturirangan High-Level Working Group (2013) scaled this to about 37% (~60,000 sq km), mostly natural landscape. ESAs are notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. The Western Ghats are a UNESCO World Heritage Site (2012) and one of the world’s biodiversity hotspots.
Twisted Graphene Shows Extreme Sensitivity to Strain
Scientists found that slightly straining magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG) changes its electrical resistance over 100 times more than in ordinary metals. Strain could become a new tool to control its quantum behaviour.
- Prelims hook: Graphene is a single layer of carbon atoms in a hexagonal lattice, isolated in 2004 by Geim and Novoselov (Nobel Prize in Physics, 2010). Stacking two layers at a ‘magic angle’ of about 1.1° makes it a superconductor (reported in 2018) — the birth of ‘twistronics’.
Concept in News — Equity vs Bonds: Concentration and Diversification
Concentrated bets (e.g. a sector fund) can pay off in equity, which has high upside. In bonds, upside is capped at the fixed interest, so diversification across sectors and maturities matters more.
- Prelims hook: a bond’s price is the present value of its future interest payments, so bond prices move inversely to interest rates. If one issuer defaults, markets may demand a higher credit risk premium from the whole sector, pulling down other bonds too. An ETF (Exchange-Traded Fund) is a fund traded on a stock exchange like a share.


