Editorials/Opinions Analysis For UPSC 12 November 2026

Legacy IAS Academy · Editorials, Opinions & Explained

Editorials & Explained — 12 November 2026

The most exam-relevant op-ed, ideas & explainer pieces · mapped to the syllabus · a Mains question with each
Op-ed Pages · Signed Opinion Crisil · CSEP
OpinionsSigned Op-eds & Ideas
01

India’s Growth Has Weathered the Shocks — Can It Turn Lucky Export Gains into Lasting Competitiveness?

Core Topic Opinion GS-III · Economy — Growth, Inflation, Monetary Policy, External Sector, Industry Prelims + Mains Op-ed · Dharmakirti Joshi (Chief Economist, Crisil)

A year of tariff wars, a West Asia conflict and disruptions around the Strait of Hormuz did not produce the feared global slump. The author credits AI-linked investment and a muted oil-price response, expects Indian growth of about 7% this fiscal, and warns that rising inflation, capital outflows and one-off export tailwinds make manufacturing competitiveness the Budget’s top task.

◈ Static Background — Reading Growth and Inflation from the Basics
  • GDP measures the value of final goods and services produced; from the demand side it is consumption + investment + government spending + net exports. Private consumption is the largest part (over half of GDP); investment is measured as Gross Fixed Capital Formation (GFCF).
  • Inflation is a sustained rise in the general price level, tracked through the Consumer Price Index (CPI) compiled by the NSO (base year revised to 2024 in February 2026). Demand-pull inflation comes from excess spending; cost-push inflation from costlier inputs such as fuel, freight or fertiliser — the kind the author describes.
  • Flexible Inflation Targeting: under Section 45ZA of the RBI Act, 1934 (amended in 2016), the Centre sets a CPI target every five years; on 25 March 2026 it retained 4% ± 2% for April 2026 – March 2031.
  • Monetary Policy Committee (MPC): six members (three from the RBI, three external) set the repo rate — the rate at which the RBI lends to banks. 25 basis points = 0.25 percentage point. Raising the repo rate cools demand and inflation but also slows growth.
  • El Niño: unusual warming of the central and eastern equatorial Pacific, often linked to a weaker Indian monsoon — hitting kharif output, reservoir levels and then the rabi crop.
◈ Static Background — External Sector and Corporate Health Terms
  • Balance of Payments: the current account records trade in goods and services and remittances; the capital account records investment flows. FDI brings a lasting stake (10% or more of a company’s equity); FPI is portfolio money in shares and bonds — faster to enter and to leave.
  • Rupee depreciation makes imports costlier (fuelling inflation) but raises the rupee value of exports — which is why petroleum exports grew far faster in rupee terms than in dollar terms.
  • Strait of Hormuz: the chokepoint between the Persian Gulf and the Gulf of Oman, through which about a fifth of global oil consumption passes. India holds strategic petroleum reserves of 5.33 million tonnes at Visakhapatnam, Mangaluru and Padur (ISPRL).
  • Credit ratio: rating upgrades divided by downgrades — above 1 means more firms improved than worsened. Debt-to-equity: borrowed funds relative to owners’ funds — lower means less leverage. EBITDA margin: operating profit (before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) as a share of revenue.
  • Household net financial savings = financial assets acquired minus new borrowing; they fell to around 5% of GDP in 2022-23, a multi-decade low, as loans grew faster than deposits.
  • LTCG tax: since July 2024, long-term gains on listed equity are taxed at 12.5% above an exemption of ₹1.25 lakh a year.
~7%Expected GDP growth this fiscal
~5.3%Expected average CPI inflation (upside risks)
+19%Merchandise exports, first half (Apr–Sep)
2.18xCrisil credit ratio, H1 (1.50x in H2 of last year)

All four figures are the author’s and Crisil’s estimates. Petroleum exports rose 37% in dollar terms and nearly 50% in rupee terms in April–September, as damage to refineries abroad lifted product prices faster than crude.

Figure 1 — How This Year’s Global Shocks Travelled into India’s Economy
The year’s global shocks West Asia conflict · Hormuz · tariffs · AI boom Costlier oil, freight, insurance imported, cost-push inflation (fuel, fertiliser, food) Capital outflows FPIs chase AI-led markets → rupee weakens Offsets for India refined-product prices up → petroleum exports +37% (USD) Central banks, including the RBI, stay tighter for longer a further 25 bp repo hike expected in December → growth moderates in H2 Cushion: reserve drawdowns kept crude’s rise muted Channels as described by the author; arrows show direction of effect, not magnitude
The same shock that raised India’s import bill also lifted its refined-product exports — a reminder that India is both a large crude importer and a major refiner. The net effect this year was growth that held up, with inflation and the rupee as the pressure points.
The Author’s Argument, in Brief
  • Why the world held up: heavy investment in AI infrastructure — data centres, chips — has driven capital spending, especially in the US; and crude prices rose less than feared as countries drew down reserves and inventories.
  • India’s first half: broad-based — public investment, strong goods exports, double-digit credit growth, demand for consumer durables (notably cars), and household spending supported by tax relief and direct benefit transfers.
  • Corporate health: upgrades outpace downgrades; median debt-to-equity near 0.5x; revenue up about 16–16.5% in July–September — but commodity producers gained while downstream manufacturers absorbed higher input costs.
  • Headwinds: CPI expected near 5.3% with upside risks; a deficient kharif monsoon, low reservoirs and a persistent El Niño; net foreign capital outflows in the first eight months exceeded those of all of last year, though November saw FPI inflows return.
  • Prescription: make manufacturing competitiveness the Budget’s focus; FTAs open doors but do not guarantee outcomes — lasting export powers cut costs, raise productivity and innovate faster than rivals. A favourable look at LTCG taxation could also support equity inflows.
Analysis — What “Competitiveness” Requires
  • Manufacturing share: still around 16–17% of GVA, short of the long-standing 25% goal first set in the National Manufacturing Policy (2011) and carried into Make in India (2014).
  • Lower costs: logistics costs of roughly 7.8–8.9% of GDP (DPIIT–NCAER estimate, 2021-22) — targeted by the National Logistics Policy (2022) and PM GatiShakti (2021); power tariffs and compliance burdens also matter.
  • Productivity: scale through PLI schemes (14 sectors, ₹1.97 lakh crore), skills, and simpler labour rules under the four Labour Codes; regulatory decriminalisation under the Jan Vishwas Act, 2023.
  • Innovation: India’s R&D spending, about 0.6–0.7% of GDP, is low; private R&D finance under the ₹1 lakh crore RDI scheme is a start.
  • Trade architecture: agreements with the UAE and Australia (2022), EFTA (in force 2025), the UK (signed 2025) and Oman (in force 2026) widen market access — but only competitive firms can use it.
The Critical View
  • Borrowed tailwinds: export gains rest partly on refinery outages abroad, high commodity prices and a weaker rupee — none of them permanent, as the author himself cautions.
  • Concentrated global engine: if the AI investment boom cools, the main prop of global demand weakens at once.
  • Household leverage: consumption financed by borrowing is less durable than consumption financed by income growth.
  • Policy trade-off: rate hikes to contain cost-push inflation may hurt growth without addressing the supply-side causes of high food and energy prices.
  • Capital flows: tax tweaks may attract portfolio money, but stable flows depend on earnings growth and macroeconomic stability more than on tax rates.
✎ Mains Practice Question

India’s economy has shown resilience amid global shocks, but part of its recent export success rests on temporary factors. Discuss the drivers of this resilience and suggest measures to build durable manufacturing competitiveness. 15 marks · 250 words

02

Turning Spent EV Batteries into Strategic Mineral Wealth: The Case for a Circular Battery Economy

Core Topic Opinion GS-III · Environment & Economy — Critical Minerals, Circular Economy, Waste Management GS-II · IR — Resource Geopolitics Prelims + Mains Op-ed · Shyamasis Das (Fellow, Centre for Social and Economic Progress)

With the Prime Minister warning at the 18th BRICS Summit in New Delhi (13 September 2026) against the “weaponisation of technology and critical minerals”, the author argues that India’s growing pile of spent lithium-ion batteries is a domestic mine waiting to be tapped — recycling could meet about 10–12% of the lithium needed for EV battery manufacturing.

◈ Static Background — Critical Minerals from the Basics
  • Definition: minerals essential to the economy and national security whose supply is scarce or geographically concentrated — lithium, nickel, cobalt, graphite and rare earths power batteries, electronics and clean energy.
  • India’s list: the Ministry of Mines identified 30 critical minerals in 2023; the MMDR Amendment Act, 2023 lets the Centre auction blocks of critical and strategic minerals and removed lithium and five others from the atomic-minerals list to open them to private mining.
  • National Critical Mineral Mission (2025): ₹16,300 crore from the Centre plus about ₹18,000 crore from PSUs (2024-25 to 2030-31) for exploration, processing, overseas assets, recycling and a National Critical Mineral Stockpile.
  • Overseas sourcing: KABIL (Khanij Bidesh India Ltd, 2019) holds lithium blocks in Argentina; India joined the US-led Mineral Security Partnership in 2023. A 5.9 million tonne inferred lithium resource was reported at Reasi (J&K) in 2023.
  • Concentration risk: China dominates global refining of lithium, cobalt, graphite and rare earths, and has imposed export controls on gallium and germanium (2023), graphite (2023) and rare earths (2025).
◈ Static Background — Inside a Lithium-Ion Battery, and How It Is Recycled
  • Anatomy: a cathode (lithium compounds such as NMC — nickel-manganese-cobalt — or LFP — lithium iron phosphate), a graphite anode, an electrolyte carrying lithium ions and a separator.
  • Second life: an EV battery is usually retired at about 70–80% of its original capacity — still useful for stationary storage before recycling.
  • Black mass: the powder left after discharging, dismantling and shredding batteries; it contains lithium, nickel, cobalt, manganese and graphite but is only an intermediate product.
  • Recovery routes: pyrometallurgy (high-temperature smelting; energy-intensive, loses lithium), hydrometallurgy (chemical leaching; higher recovery of battery-grade salts) and emerging direct recycling (restoring cathode material).
  • Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR): a polluter-pays rule making producers responsible for collecting and recycling what they sell, usually through tradable EPR certificates.
▤ Policy at a Glance — Battery Waste Management Rules, 2022 and Recycling Support
  • Notified by: MoEFCC on 24 August 2022 under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, replacing the 2001 rules; covers EV, portable, automotive and industrial batteries.
  • EPR: producers must meet collection and recycling obligations, tracked on a centralised CPCB portal with tradable EPR certificates; violations attract environmental compensation.
  • Recovery targets for recyclers (share of battery dry weight): 70% (2024-25) → 80% (2025-26) → 90% from 2026-27 for EV and portable batteries.
  • Recycled content: from 2027-28, new batteries must contain a minimum share of domestically recycled material, rising over time.
  • Incentive Scheme for Critical Mineral Recycling: ₹1,500 crore under the NCMM (approved September 2025, running to 2030-31) — capital and operating support for plants that recover minerals; units producing only black mass are excluded.
  • EV base: more than 8.7 million EVs on Indian roads by FY 2025-26, backed by FAME, PM E-DRIVE (2024) and the PLI scheme for Advanced Chemistry Cells (2021).
Figure 2 — Closing the Battery Loop
1 · Primary supply mining · imports · KABIL 2 · Cell manufacturing design for recycling 3 · First life in EVs 8.7 million EVs (FY26) 4 · Second life stationary storage 5 · Collection take-back · buy-back · EPR 6 · Formal recycling black mass → refined salts Leakage: informal landfill / kabadiwala batteries not collected formally leak to informal channels recycled minerals back to manufacturing Recovery rate: informal 10–20% formal 90%+
Every battery that slips into informal channels takes most of its minerals with it. Collection — not recycling technology alone — is the weakest link, which is why the author stresses take-back schemes and public participation.
Figure 3 — Material Recovery: Informal Practice vs Formal Targets (%)
10–20 70 80 90 90+ Informal sector(reported) BWMR target2024-25 BWMR target2025-26 BWMR targetfrom 2026-27 Formal facilities(reported)
The legal target already assumes formal-grade recovery; the gap is in getting batteries to formal recyclers. Informal bar drawn at the midpoint of the reported range; all bars to scale (1.6 px per percentage point).
The Author’s Argument, in Brief
  • A mine at home: spent batteries are a “waste-to-wealth” resource; recycling will not make India self-sufficient but can be a strategic secondary source alongside mining and imports, and build the processing capability India lacks.
  • Plan ahead: volumes are small now, but “just-in-time” investment will not work — capacity must be built before the surge, even if plants run below capacity at first.
  • Five-point strategy: (1) a mandated share of recycled minerals in the proposed national stockpile, nudging recyclers beyond black mass; (2) R&D for higher recovery and purity across diverse chemistries; (3) standards for battery characterisation, recycled-mineral quality and second-life use, with “design for repurposing and recycling”; (4) easy take-back or buy-back through EV makers and dealers; (5) patient capital for long-gestation plants.
Why It Matters
  • Strategic autonomy: recycled minerals are immune to foreign export bans once they are inside the country.
  • Environment: landfilled lithium-ion batteries can catch fire and leach toxic substances; formal recycling also avoids the land and water impacts of fresh mining.
  • Industrial opportunity: recycling plants create domestic refining skills that can later serve mined ore too — a step into the processing stage China now dominates.
  • Climate goals: a circular battery chain lowers the lifecycle emissions of EVs, supporting India’s net-zero 2070 pathway (and SDG 12 on responsible consumption).
The Critical View
  • Chemistry shift: the move to LFP batteries, which contain no nickel or cobalt, lowers the value recyclers can recover, weakening plant economics.
  • Price swings: volatile lithium prices can make recycled material uncompetitive with fresh imports in some years — the reason stockpile purchases or price support are proposed.
  • Timing of collection: EV batteries can last a decade; EPR collection targets based on conservative battery-life assumptions risk forcing early retirement.
  • Informal workers: lakhs of kabadiwalas depend on scrap; formalisation should integrate them as collectors and aggregators rather than shut them out.
  • Enforcement: EPR systems depend on verifying certificates and recycler claims; weak checks undermine the whole chain.
✎ Mains Practice Question

“The EV revolution should not end when a battery leaves the vehicle.” Examine how battery recycling can contribute to India’s critical mineral security, and discuss the regulatory and economic challenges in building a circular battery economy. 15 marks · 250 words

Legacy IAS Academy · Editorials, Opinions & Explained 12 November 2026 · Op-ed Pages & Crisil

Book a Free Demo Class

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
Categories

Get free Counselling and ₹25,000 Discount

Fill the form – Our experts will call you within 30 mins.