A Private Member Bill seeks to amend Article 124 to mandate regional SC benches and reform judicial appointments — reviving the Collegium vs NJAC debate.
GS 2 — Polity & Governance
→ Article 124 reform & Collegium vs NJAC
→ Basic Structure Doctrine
→ Regional benches under Article 130
• Article 124 — SC judges appointed by President after consultation with judiciary.
• 2nd Judges Case (1993) and 3rd Judges Case (1998) established Collegium primacy — CJI + 4 senior judges recommend appointments.
• 99th CAA (2014) created NJAC — struck down in SC Advocates-on-Record Association v. UoI (2015) for violating Basic Structure.
• Article 130 permits SC to sit elsewhere with Presidential approval — never permanently operationalised.
🏛️ Governance & Access to Justice
• SC operates only from New Delhi — limiting access for southern, eastern, and NE litigants.
• Over 90,000 pending cases reflect centralised backlog pressures.
• Law Commission 229th Report (2009) — recommended Constitution Bench in Delhi + regional Cassation Benches for appellate work.
• Marginalised groups (SC/ST/OBC, women) remain disproportionately underrepresented in higher judiciary.
🔄 Challenges & Way Forward
Challenges
✗ Altering appointments risks basic structure confrontation
✗ Executive involvement may dilute judicial independence
✗ Regional benches could cause forum shopping
✗ Political resistance and institutional mistrust
Way Forward
✓ Publish Collegium selection criteria and reasons
✓ Regional benches for appellate; Constitution Bench in Delhi
✓ Diversity benchmarks without formal quotas
✓ Strengthen digitisation and hybrid hearings
📌 Prelims Pointers
📌 Art 124 — SC establishment & appointments
📌 Art 130 — SC seat & possible alternate locations
📌 99th CAA 2014 — Created NJAC (struck down 2015)
📌 2nd & 3rd Judges Cases — Collegium primacy established
📌 Judicial independence is part of the Basic Structure Doctrine
📝 Prelims MCQ
QUESTION 1
Consider the following: 1. NJAC was established by the 99th Constitutional Amendment Act. 2. NJAC was struck down for violating the Basic Structure Doctrine. 3. The Collegium was established through a Parliamentary Act.
Which is/are correct?
A. 1 only
B. 1 and 2 only
C. 2 and 3 only
D. 1, 2 and 3
Answer: (B) 1 and 2 only The Collegium was created through judicial interpretation (Judges Cases), not by any Parliamentary legislation. Statement 3 is wrong.
QUESTION 2
The Law Commission’s 229th Report (2009) recommended:
A. Abolishing the Supreme Court
B. Constitution Bench in Delhi + regional Cassation Benches
C. Executive-led appointments body
D. Making High Court decisions non-appealable
Answer: (B) The 229th Report recommended a Constitution Bench at Delhi for constitutional matters and regional Cassation Benches for appellate work — improving geographic access to justice.
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION
“Discuss the constitutional and governance implications of establishing regional benches of the Supreme Court and reforming the judicial appointments process in India.”
(250 Words | 15 Marks)
Approach: Intro: Private Member Bill — Art 124 amendment context. Body: Collegium strengths (independence) vs weaknesses (opacity). NJAC — 99th CAA struck down — Basic Structure. Regional benches — Art 130, 229th Report, 90K+ pendency. Forum shopping risk. SC/ST/OBC/women underrepresentation — Art 14, 16. Conclusion: Transparent Collegium + appellate regional benches + diversity benchmarks + digital courts.
National integration Tribal community support Education & health
Constitutional
Art 355 — Union duty Art 38 — inequalities Union List Entry 1&2
📊 Way Forward — Flowchart
1
Integrated Border Framework — Combine security, infrastructure, and human development metrics.
2
Community Participation — Context-specific livelihood models through local planning.
3
Green Infrastructure — Climate resilience in fragile border ecosystems.
4
Digital Connectivity — Integrate border youth into national skilling platforms.
5
Outcome Monitoring — Periodic evaluation with outcome-based indicators.
📌 Prelims Pointers
📌 VVP-I: 2023 (China border only)
📌 VVP-II: April 2025 — 1,954 villages across 5 borders
📌 “Last Village–First Village” approach
📌 Launch: Nathanpur village, Cachar district, Assam
📝 Prelims MCQ
QUESTION 3
VVP Phase II covers border areas along how many neighbouring countries?
A. 3 (China, Pakistan, Nepal)
B. 4 (China, Pakistan, Nepal, Myanmar)
C. 5 (Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Myanmar)
D. 6 (all land neighbours)
Answer: (C) — VVP-II expands from China-only Phase I to 5 borders: Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Myanmar.
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION
“Border security cannot rely solely on military preparedness; it requires developmental integration.” Examine VVP Phase II.
(250 Words | 15 Marks)
Approach: Intro: Border as development frontier. Body: VVP-I→II expansion. Security — Art 355, populated villages as deterrence. Economic — livelihoods, tourism. Social — national integration, tribal areas. Challenges — terrain, coordination. Conclusion: Integrated framework: security + development + digital connectivity.
📌 Caretta caretta | Vulnerable (IUCN) — NOT Endangered 📌 Temperature-dependent sex determination 📌 Capital breeders | Major nesting: Cabo Verde
QUESTION 4
Consider: 1. Loggerheads are Endangered on IUCN Red List. 2. They exhibit temperature-dependent sex determination. 3. They are “capital breeders.”
Which is/are correct?
A. 1 and 2 only
B. 2 and 3 only
C. 1 and 3 only
D. 1, 2 and 3
Answer: (B) — Loggerheads are Vulnerable, not Endangered. Statements 2 & 3 are correct.
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION
“Climate change affects marine species not only through habitat loss but also by altering reproductive biology.” Discuss with reference to loggerhead turtles.
(250 Words | 15 Marks)
Approach: Four pathways (warming, productivity, sea-level, sand temp). Reproductive impacts — interval 2→4 yrs, clutch & body size. India — Olive ridley, Gahirmatha, NAPCC. Expand MPAs beyond nesting beaches. International marine cooperation.
India’s $300B+ IT sector must pivot from coding arbitrage to AI deployment & enterprise transformation.
$300B+
IT sector size
5M+
IT professionals
• “Deployment gap” = lag between AI innovation and enterprise-scale implementation — India’s opportunity space.
• AI automates coding/testing but enterprise adoption limited by legacy systems and governance concerns.
• New roles: AI trainers, system integrators, data governance specialists, workflow designers.
• India can become the world’s largest AI implementation hub leveraging its workforce scale.
Challenges
✗ AI evolution outpaces reskilling ✗ Smaller firms can’t afford transition ✗ Data privacy & ethical AI gaps ✗ Global recession compounds pressure
Way Forward
✓ Large-scale AI reskilling for 5M+ ✓ MSME AI adoption incentives ✓ PPP for domain-specific AI ✓ Shift narrative: loss → transformation
QUESTION 5
The “Deployment Gap” in AI refers to:
A. Gap in AI research funding between India and China
B. Gap between AI innovation and enterprise-scale implementation
C. Gap between IT hiring demand and graduate supply
D. Gap in India’s AI patents vs global average
Answer: (B)
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION
“AI may not eliminate India’s IT industry but transform its nature.” Examine the ‘deployment gap’ thesis.
(250 Words)
Approach: IT sector context. Disruption — coding automation. Deployment gap opportunity. New roles — AI trainers, architects. Policy — India AI Mission, MSME, education. Global positioning. Reskilling + policy clarity.
Geopolitics & energy security now drive clean energy innovation alongside climate goals. 320+ start-ups funded in 2025, but the “valley of death” persists.
640
Technologies tracked
320+
Start-ups funded
0.1%
GDP R&D target
32+13
IEA members + associates
• “Valley of death” = funding gap between prototype and commercial-scale deployment.
• 640 technologies tracked — many technically mature but blocked by regulatory/market barriers.
• Nuclear fusion milestones in 2025 (Germany, UK, China, France, US) but commercial deployment remains distant.
• India (IEA Association Country) targeting 500 GW non-fossil capacity by 2030.
Challenges
✗ “Valley of death” funding gap ✗ Regulatory inertia on grid tech ✗ Uneven R&D across regions ✗ Geopolitical fragmentation
Way Forward
✓ Public R&D toward 0.1% GDP ✓ Grid modernisation policies ✓ Procurement for green H₂ & storage ✓ International research platforms
QUESTION 6
India’s status with the IEA is:
A. Full member
B. Association Country
C. Observer only
D. Not affiliated
Answer: (B) — India is an IEA Association Country, not a full member.
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION
“Energy innovation is shaped as much by geopolitics as by climate goals.” Discuss with IEA 2026 insights and India’s priorities.
Approach: IEA context. Geopolitics & supply chains. 640 tech but deployment gap. Nuclear fusion. India — 500 GW, grid modernisation. R&D 0.1% GDP, procurement, international cooperation.
ISA launched AI-for-Energy Mission at India AI Impact Summit — AI + citizen-centric platforms for 120+ member countries. India’s DPI model as replicable template.
• AI enhances grid resilience, bidirectional power flows, demand forecasting, distributed solar integration.
• Prosumers (producer-consumers) with rooftop solar require intelligent grid management.
• Digital Twin technologies enable real-time simulation and predictive maintenance.
📌 ISA: 2015 | HQ Gurugram (NOT New Delhi) | 120+ members 📌 AI-for-Energy Mission launched at AI Impact Summit 2026 📌 India target: 500 GW non-fossil by 2030
QUESTION 7
ISA is headquartered in:
A. New Delhi
B. Gurugram
C. Geneva
D. Nairobi
Answer: (B) Gurugram
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION
“Digital infrastructure is central to the clean energy transition.” Examine ISA’s AI-for-Energy Mission for developing economies.
Approach: ISA context — 120+ members. AI capabilities — grid, prosumers, digital twins. India DPI model. SDG 7,9,13. Challenges — digital divide, capital. South-South cooperation.
17+ year study shows LTMs surviving in plantation landscapes, challenging extinction assumptions — but stability is ecologically fragile.
• Macaca silenus — Endangered (IUCN) | Endemic to Western Ghats evergreen forests.
• Troops persisted 40+ years in Valparai plantation fragments — defying island-biogeography predictions.
• Behavioural plasticity: road crossing, ground movement — but increases mortality (vehicles, electrocution, feral dogs).
• Conservation policy must shift from fortress protection → landscape-level management: canopy bridges, corridor restoration, cumulative EIAs.
Challenges
✗ Genetic isolation despite demographic stability ✗ Infrastructure outpacing corridor restoration ✗ Climate stress on montane rainforests ✗ Uneven mitigation across states
Way Forward
✓ Landscape-level planning with plantations ✓ Canopy connectivity for gene flow ✓ Cumulative biodiversity-inclusive EIAs ✓ Plantation ESG collaboration
📌 Prelims Pointers
📌 Macaca silenus | Endangered (IUCN) 📌 Endemic to Western Ghats (NOT Eastern Ghats) 📌 Stronghold: Silent Valley National Park 📌 WPA 1972 | W. Ghats UNESCO WHS 2012
QUESTION 8
The lion-tailed macaque is endemic to:
A. Eastern Ghats
B. Western Ghats
C. Northeast India
D. Andaman & Nicobar Islands
Answer: (B) Western Ghats
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION
“Fragmentation does not always lead to immediate extinction.” Discuss with reference to the lion-tailed macaque and landscape-level conservation.
Approach: Challenge conventional view. 17-yr Anamalai research. Persistence in fragments — but genetic isolation risk. Fortress → landscape policy shift. Tools: canopy bridges, corridors, EIAs, plantation ESG. Legal: WPA 1972, Art 48A, W. Ghats ESA. Stability ≠ recovery.
What is the Collegium system and why is it controversial?▼
The Collegium is where the CJI + 4 senior SC judges recommend appointments. Created through the 2nd & 3rd Judges Cases (judicial interpretation, not legislation). Criticised for opacity — no published criteria — and perpetuating social homogeneity with SC/ST/OBC/women underrepresented.
Why was the NJAC struck down?▼
The SC held in 2015 that NJAC (99th CAA) violated the Basic Structure — specifically judicial independence. Two “eminent persons” nominated by PM, CJI, and Leader of Opposition were seen as giving executive undue influence.
🏔️ Vibrant Village Programme
What is the “Last Village–First Village” approach?▼
Instead of neglecting border villages as remote peripheries, VVP reframes them as India’s “first village” — frontline assets deserving priority investment in infrastructure, livelihoods, healthcare, education, and connectivity to reverse depopulation.
🐢 Loggerhead Turtles
What is temperature-dependent sex determination?▼
Sex of offspring determined by incubation temperature, not chromosomes. Warmer sand = more females. Climate-driven warming is skewing ratios heavily female, potentially collapsing breeding populations.
What does “capital breeder” mean?▼
An animal that stores energy over years before investing in reproduction. Declining ocean productivity extends energy accumulation time — breeding intervals stretched from 2 to 4 years, halving lifetime reproductive output.
💻 AI & Indian IT
What is the “deployment gap” in AI?▼
The gap between cutting-edge AI innovation (US/Chinese firms) and enterprise-scale implementation. Most businesses struggle to integrate AI into legacy systems. This gap is India’s opportunity to pivot from coding services to AI deployment consulting.
⚡ IEA & ISA
What is the “valley of death” in clean energy?▼
The critical funding gap between prototype/demonstration and commercial-scale deployment. Many innovations fail here despite being technically proven. IEA recommends public procurement, stable policy, and targeted R&D funding.
What are “prosumers” in the energy context?▼
Consumers who also produce energy via rooftop solar. They consume from the grid and feed excess back. Managing millions of prosumers requires AI-enabled grid systems for bidirectional flows, net metering, and demand forecasting.
🐒 Lion-Tailed Macaque
What is “fortress protection” vs landscape-level conservation?▼
Fortress = protecting species only within national parks. Landscape-level = integrating conservation across entire landscapes including plantations, fragments, corridors. Tools: canopy bridges, corridor mapping, plantation company ESG partnerships, biodiversity-inclusive EIAs.
What was the Silent Valley movement?▼
1970s-80s Kerala campaign against a dam in Silent Valley tropical forest. Scientists and activists prevented the dam → Silent Valley National Park (1984). A milestone in India’s environmental politics and key lion-tailed macaque stronghold.
Legacy IAS — Bangalore
UPSC Civil Services Coaching | Current Affairs — 19 February 2026