Call Us Now

+91 9606900005 / 04

For Enquiry

legacyiasacademy@gmail.com

Editorials/Opinions Analysis For UPSC 08 October 2025

  1. A path to progress that is paved with gold
  2. It’s time for Maoists to lay down arms


Context and Why in News ?

  • The editorial emphasizes Atmanirbharta (self-reliance) as a philosophy beyond economics, calling for financial self-reliance through domestic capital mobilization, especially gold monetisation.
  • Context:
    • Global FDI and project finance declined in 2024 (FDI -11%, project finance -27%).
    • Rising global interest rates and deglobalisation increase vulnerability of external capital dependence.
    • India holds $2.4 trillion worth of household gold (25,000 tonnes) — untapped domestic wealth.

Relevance:

  • GS2 (Governance & Economic Policy)
    • Financial self-reliance, gold monetisation schemes, domestic resource mobilisation.
  • GS3 (Economy & Macro-finance)
    • Balance of Payments (gold imports vs domestic holdings).
    • Impact on Current Account Deficit (CAD) and external borrowing.

Practice Question:

  • Discuss the paradox of Indias gold holdings and imports. How does it impact Indias macroeconomic stability?(250 Words)

Meaning and Evolution of Atmanirbharta

  • Etymology: “Atmanirbharta” = self-reliance; “Atma” (self) + “Nirbharta” (dependence).
  • Philosophical meaning: Inner strength leading to global confidence.
  • Economic meaning: Building domestic capacity to reduce external dependence and enhance resilience.

Historical Phases of Indian Self-Reliance

Phase Crisis Self-Reliance Response Outcome
1960s Food crisis Green Revolution Food self-sufficiency
1990s Tech transition IT & digital revolution Global digital hub
2020 COVID pandemic Indigenous vaccines & pharma Vaccine self-reliance
2020s Defence dependence Indigenisation under Make in India Towards strategic autonomy
2025 (current) Capital dependency Financial Atmanirbharta Mobilising domestic wealth

Problem Statement: External Capital Dependence

  • FDI inflows since 2000: > $1 trillion (gross).
  • But: External capital is volatile and cyclical, influenced by global liquidity and geopolitics.
  • Indias future growth (target: $5 trillion economy) cannot hinge on foreign savings alone.
  • Hence, need to tap Indias own household and institutional wealth.

India’s Gold Paradox

1. Scale of Wealth

  • Gold holdings: ~25,000 tonnes (world’s largest private reserve).
  • Value: ~$2.4 trillion = 55% of Indias GDP (FY26 est.).
  • Comparison: Exceeds total bank credit outstanding in India.

2. Paradox of Import Dependence

  • 87% of demand met via imports.
  • Gold imports = 8% of total import bill; contributed ~33% of trade deficit (2010–13).
  • Thus, despite huge domestic reserves, India continues to import gold, worsening CAD.

The Case for Gold Monetisation

Why Monetisation Matters

  • Unlock idle household gold → formal financial capital → domestic credit expansion.
  • Reduces gold imports → improves current account balance.
  • Creates a low-cost fund source (4.5–6.5%) compared to external borrowing costs (~8–9%).
  • Aligns with financial inclusion, Make in India, and National Infrastructure Pipeline (NIP) funding goals.

Challenges with Past Schemes

Issue Description
Trust deficit Fear of purity mismatch, bureaucratic scrutiny, and taxation deterred depositors.
Infrastructure gaps Limited hallmarking and purity testing centres.
Complex procedures Gold Monetisation Scheme (GMS, 2015) suffered from low awareness and complicated documentation.
Low institutional capacity Banks lacked expertise in physical gold logistics.

Proposed Framework for a Reimagined Gold Monetisation Model

1. Infrastructure Expansion

  • Scale hallmarking and purity testing centres under BIS.
  • Network of collection & assaying centres nationwide.
  • As of 2025, BIS-registered centres have doubled, but coverage remains urban-centric.

2. Logistics Framework

  • Banks: Manage fund flows.
  • Certified agencies: Handle gold movement, storage, and security transparently.
  • Use of insured, digitally tracked channels.

3. Digitalisation & Transparency

  • Each depositor should access metal balance digitally, akin to a savings account.
  • Use of mobile apps, digital ledgers, and blockchain to track gold flow and prevent fraud.

4. Policy & Trust Enablers

  • Remove GST/customs scrutiny for deposited gold.
  • Simplify KYC: “No questions asked” assurance for household deposits.
  • Assured returns and transparency in redemption value.

Economic Impact Estimate

Impact Area Mechanism Expected Outcome
External sector Reduction in gold imports Improves CAD stability
Banking sector Low-cost fund mobilisation Expands credit for infra & MSMEs
Monetary policy Enhances domestic liquidity Reduces external vulnerability
Investment cycle Domestic wealth recycling Boosts private capital formation
Employment Growth in hallmarking, logistics, fintech Creates new skill-based jobs

Philosophical and Civilisational Angle

  • Gold monetisation isn’t just financial — it’s civilisational self-trust.
  • Echoes India’s ethos of self-sufficiency through shared participation, not coercion.
  • Reinforces the Atmanirbhar spirit: “Bharat can fund Bharat.”

Way Forward

  1. Public awareness campaigns to build trust and participation.
  2. PPP model for hallmarking & logistics infrastructure.
  3. Digital gold exchange under SEBI for transparency.
  4. Integration with UPI & Jan Dhan to reach rural households.
  5. Financial literacy drive linking gold to productive savings.
  6. Periodic audit & publication of gold mobilisation data.

Conclusion

  • Atmanirbharta 2.0 = Financial Sovereignty.
  • Mobilising India’s domestic gold wealth represents the next major self-reliance revolution — akin to the Green and Digital Revolutions.
  • Success depends on trust, technology, and transparency — turning cultural assets into developmental capital.
  • The goal: India financing India, ensuring sustainable, sovereign, and inclusive growth.


Why in News

  • Union Home Minister ruled out talks with Maoists, urging them to surrender under the governments rehabilitation policy.
  • Government aims for complete Maoist eradication by next year (2026).
  • Editorial argues that the CPI (Maoist) is at its weakest point in history, both militarily and ideologically.

Relevance

  • GS2 (Governance & Internal Security)
    • Counter-insurgency policies: SAMADHAN doctrine, DRG, CoBRA deployment.
  • GS3 (Internal Security & Defence)
    • Left-Wing Extremism (LWE) as an internal security challenge.

Practice Questions

  • Analyse the factors leading to the decline of the Maoist movement in India. How can governance and development interventions consolidate this success? (250 Words)

Understanding Left-Wing Extremism (LWE)

  • Definition: A violent movement seeking to overthrow the democratic State through armed struggle, based on Maoist ideology.
  • Main group:Communist Party of India (Maoist) — formed in 2004 through the merger of:
    • CPI (Marxist–Leninist) People’s War Group (PWG)
    • Maoist Communist Centre of India (MCCI)
  • Core Ideology: Inspired by Mao Zedongs Protracted Peoples War — to capture rural areas, encircle cities, and seize state power.
  • Peak Influence: Around 2009–2011, LWE affected over 200 districts across 20 states (“Red Corridor”).

The Present Context — A Movement in Decline

Organisational Weakness

Year Central Committee Members Politburo Members Cadre Strength
2004 42 25 ~10,000
2025 13 7–8 <2,000
  •  
  • Most top leaders are over 60, ailing, and fatigued.
  • The Central Committee has shrunk drastically; no fresh intellectual leadership has emerged.
  • Internal divisions and leadership crisis following the death of General Secretary Nambala Keshava Rao (Basavaraju).

Geographic Decline

  • Once-dominant in Andhra Pradesh, Odisha, and Chhattisgarh.
  • After police modernization in Andhra and Odisha, they were pushed into Chhattisgarhs dense forests.
  • Even their Liberated Zone” in South Bastar (Sukma, Dantewada, Bijapur, Narayanpur) is now fragmented.
  • Maoist influence in Jharkhand and Bihar also significantly reduced due to coordinated inter-State operations.

Turning Point in Counter-Insurgency

1. Security Reforms

  • Commando Battalion for Resolute Action (CoBRA) – specialized CRPF unit trained in jungle warfare.
  • District Reserve Guard (DRG):
    • Comprised of surrendered Maoists and ex-Salwa Judum members.
    • Highly effective due to local terrain familiarity.
    • Crucial in Operation Black Forest — destroyed Maoist HQ at Karregutta hills.

2. Operational Outcomes (2024–25)

  • Maoists killed: ~430 (including 5 Central Committee members and 45 women cadres).
  • Surrenders: ~1,450 Maoists.
  • Arrests: ~1,460.
  • Leadership elimination: 5 senior-most commanders, including General Secretary Basavaraju.

Internal Crisis: Ideological and Social Faultlines

1. Leadership vs. Cadre Divide

  • Leaders: Predominantly upper-caste, from Andhra Pradesh and Telangana.
  • Cadres: Primarily tribal, especially Gonds of Chhattisgarh.
  • Emerging identity friction between ideological leadership and ground-level fighters.

2. Shift in Motivation

  • Tribal recruits joined not from ideology but due to cultural mobilisation — songs, plays, and propaganda by Maoist cultural wings.
  • Ideological conviction diluted; tribal participation increasingly coerced or survival-driven.

3. Intellectual Decline

  • In early decades, supported by urban intellectuals and students (e.g., post-Naxalbari 1967 phase).
  • Today, no urban sympathy networks, weak political articulation, and loss of ideological legitimacy.

Role of State Response

1. Effective Counter-Insurgency Model

  • Multi-pronged: Security + Development + Governance.
  • Enhanced coordination between State Police and Central Forces under SAMADHAN doctrine (Smart Leadership, Aggressive Strategy, Motivation, etc.).
  • Improved Intelligence sharing and use of drones, GIS mapping, and satellite data for real-time tracking.
  • Rehabilitation & Surrender Policy: Monetary incentives, housing, skill training, and employment opportunities for surrendered Maoists.

2. Development Push

  • Aspirational District Programme, Road Connectivity (PMGSY), Eklavya Model Schools, and Jan Dhan–AadhaarMobile (JAM) architecture reducing isolation of tribal regions.
  • Integrated Tribal Development Projects addressing the socioeconomic roots of insurgency.

Chhattisgarh – A Unique Case Study

  • Unlike Andhra or Bengal, Maoism in Chhattisgarh was imported, not indigenous.
  • Served as a strategic retreat zone after losses elsewhere.
  • Salwa Judum (2005–07): State-sponsored militia movement —
    • Initially aimed to counter Maoists but led to atrocities against tribals.
    • Many displaced tribals later joined Maoists — backfiring effect.
  • Now, DRG (District Reserve Guard) — formed from reformed Judum cadres — has reversed that narrative effectively.

Causes of Maoist Decline

  1. Leadership vacuum after deaths/arrests of key figures.
  2. Technological edge of security forces.
  3. Erosion of urban-intellectual support.
  4. Improved tribal welfare schemes reducing alienation.
  5. Diminished ideological appeal in the era of democratic empowerment.
  6. Internal ethnic and caste divides.
  7. Rise of local governance institutions (PESA, Gram Sabhas) empowering tribals directly.
  8. Infiltration of surrendered cadres (DRG) into Maoist structures disrupting operational secrecy.

Lessons and Way Forward

1. Security Consolidation

  • Maintain high-intensity operations until complete dismantling of Maoist bases.
  • Focus on border coordination among affected states.
  • Deploy technology-driven policing (AI surveillance, drones, satellite tracking).

2. Governance Continuity

  • Prevent re-emergence by filling the governance vacuum post-clearance.
  • Prioritise land rights, forest livelihoods, and tribal inclusion.
  • Implement PESA & FRA in spirit to empower Gram Sabhas.

3. Rehabilitation & Reintegration

  • Strengthen surrender and rehabilitation schemes — skill training, psychological counselling, and employment.
  • Showcase success stories of reformed cadres to build trust.

4. Preventing Ideological Resurgence

  • Promote democratic activism and civil society participation for grievance redress.
  • Encourage peaceful, rights-based movements like Niyamgiri and Sompeta, which achieved results without violence.

Broader Message

  • Violence-based movements are unsustainable in democratic societies.
  • The Maoist decline shows the success of India’s democratic resilience, security modernisation, and developmental governance.
  • True empowerment of tribal and backward areas must come from participatory governance, not armed rebellion.

Conclusion

  • The Maoist movement, once India’s gravest internal security threat, is now at its lowest ebb.
  • Sustained reforms in security capacity, development outreach, and political inclusion have reversed the insurgency.
  • The message is clear:
    “Where democratic development delivers, extremism declines.”

  • The final step is ensuring that post-conflict zones remain peace zones, through justice, inclusion, and dignity for tribal communities — the true meaning of mainstreaming.

October 2025
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  
Categories