Call Us Now

+91 9606900005 / 04

For Enquiry

legacyiasacademy@gmail.com

Hydrogen versus battery: The cost of clean public transport

Context: Urbanisation & Pollution Challenge

  • By 2050, ~70% of people in developing countries will live in urban areas → higher demand for clean public transport.
  • In India, PM2.5 pollution caused ~30,000 deaths annually (2008–2019) in 10 major cities.
    • Highest in Mumbai (5,100), followed by Kolkata (4,678) and Chennai (2,870).

Relevance : GS 1(Society, Urbanisation),GS 3((Technology)

Rise of Electric Vehicles (EVs)

  • Global EV count reached 40 million in 2023 (35% rise from 2022).
  • Dominated by battery electric vehicles (BEVs).
  • Majority of EV sales:
    • China (over 50%)
    • Europe and the U.S. follow.

BEVs vs. FCEVs (Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles)

Fuel Cell Advantages:

  • Faster refuelling (5–15 minutes).
  • Longer range and better for extreme climates or terrain.
  • Lighter weight due to high energy density.

Current Status:

  • FCEVs = 93,000 units globally (1 for every 330 BEVs).
  • High upfront cost: 20–30% more expensive than BEVs.
  • Prices of FCEVs and BEVs expected to converge by 2030.

Operational Costs Comparison (per km):

  • Diesel bus: $0.27
  • Electric bus: $0.17 (cheapest)
  • Blue hydrogen bus: $0.84
  • Green hydrogen bus: $0.91
    ➡ Hydrogen vehicles remain economically unviable for now.

India’s EV Landscape (2023):

  • EVs = 5% of total vehicle sales.
  • Electric cars: 80,000 units (70% YoY growth).
  • Three-wheelers:
    • India leads globally (0.58 million units), surpassing China.
    • India = 60% of global electric 3-wheeler sales.
  • Two-wheelers:
    • India = second-largest market (0.88 million units).
    • China leads with 6 million units.
    • China, India, ASEAN dominate >95% of global e-2W and e-3W market.

Key Takeaway

  • Battery electric vehicles are currently more cost-effective and widely adopted.
  • Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles have niche advantages but remain costly to operate and rare.
  • India’s growth is strongest in electric 2- and 3-wheelers, aligning with urban mobility needs.

Categories